With the explosion of The Hunger Games series, there will no doubt be a run of companion pieces, pastiches, and general spin-offs. In a crowded market place, the need to set oneself apart is self-evident. Whilst the packaging of Katniss the Cattail is slightly below par, the content is anything but. Frankel's approach is thorough and academically-minded. The conscientious bibliography at the end of the book attests to this fact, and yet the book is not simply an exercise in facticity. It becomes clear very quickly that Frankel is passionate about mythology and the etymology of names, as well as fantasy literature and the subtle allusions that authors make throughout their works, and that she takes great pleasure in enhancing readers' enjoyment of the source text through her own contribution and explanatory work. In relation to The Hunger Games, many of the references that Frankel picks out relate to either Shakespeare’s or Plutarch’s accounts of Roman times, although she also draws on fantasy traditions and myths.
Frankel writes well, if not a little academically. Indeed, whilst the content is often illuminating, one suspects that it is The Hunger Games' more mature readers that will get the most from Katniss the Cattail, with younger readers possibly finding the topics discussed a little dry and heavy. That the content is so neatly laid out negates this to an extent, with the structure lending itself to reference use, rather than as a book to be read cover-to-cover. As a product of a small publishing company, there are some elements of the editing that leave a little to be desired, perhaps most notably the inconsistent use of the possessive with regards to Collins's and Katniss's names.
Readers will certainly find Frankel’s assertions and explanations illuminating and through them will gain a further understanding of Suzanne Collins’s reference points. As a whole the book's packaging could have been better designed and the editing a little more thorough, but it is for the content that one reads a book like Katniss the Cattail. I defer entirely to Frankel on the matters discussed within her slip of a book; to my knowledge her explanations and identifications appear valid and well-researched, and one can ask for little more than this. As a guide to the series, readers of could do a lot worse than Katniss the Cattail; an intelligent and informative look at Suzanne Collins's trilogy.
Reviews of Katniss the Cattail on Amazon (UK)
Reviews of Katniss the Cattail on Amazon (US)
|Interview: Valerie Estelle Frankel|
Valerie Estelle Frankel is an English professor and fantasy enthuiast. After earning her BA at UC Davis, she became the youngest person ever to receive a Master of Fine Arts in Creative Writing from San Jose State University. She enjoys dancing, acting.... [Read More]
|Review: The Hunger Games by Suzanne Collins (Book 1, The Hunger Games)|
The Hunger Games (2008) is a dystopian novel that imagines a North American of the future, where the country has been split into 12 separate districts, which are presided over by the... [Read More]
|Review: Catching Fire by Suzanne Collins (Book 2, The Hunger Games)|
Catching Fire (2009) is the second book in Suzanne Collins’s best-selling Hunger Games trilogy. Having escaped from the 74th games with both Peeta’s and her own life intact... [Read More]
|Review: Mockingjay by Suzanne Collins (Book 3, The Hunger Games)|
Mockingjay (2010) is the final book in Suzanne Collins’s Hunger Games Trilogy. Having escaped her second Hunger Games, Katniss Everdeen is cared for, with her family, in district 13; stronghold of the rebels. As she recovers her strength Katniss... [Read More]
|Word Search #002: The Hunger Games Characters|
The Hunger Games is full of fantastically named characters. Hidden within the word search below are the names of eight characters from the series (first names only). How many can you find? (Hint: this is very difficult, so I have posted the 8 names... [Read More]