Review: Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire by J. K. Rowling (Book 4, Harry Potter)

No comments

Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire by J. K. Rowling book cover
Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire (2000) is the fourth book in J. K. Rowling's wizarding series. Rescued from his regular Summer holidays in Privet Drive, Harry is taken by the Weasley family to watch the Quidditch World Cup final, which is being hosted by England. With wizards from around the world attending this global event, Harry enjoys the Quidditch match enormously, but the evening is soured by a group of hooded trouble-makers who levitate a local muggle family and conjure the Dark Mark (Voldemort's symbol) in the sky after the match. With the wizarding community unsettled by this brazen and cruel reminder of bad times past, Harry returns to Hogwarts to find that the school is hosting an international tournament of its own. The newly-reinstated Tri-Wizard Tournament is a test of wizarding mettle which brings together students from three of the largest wizarding schools in the world: Beauxbaton from France, Durmstrang from Eastern Europe, and of course, Hogwarts. Students from each school (who are over the age of 17) are eligible to enter by submitting their names to the Goblet of Fire. At a large ceremony the Goblet then selects a champion from each school, who will face a series of judged tasks over the course of the year in the hope of being crowned Tri-Wizard champion. Harry is unexpectedly chosen as a fourth champion and, despite protestations from himself and the other competitors (Cedric Diggory, Viktor Krum, and Fleur Delacour), is forced to compete in a series of increasingly dangerous tasks. Aside from the tournament, there's a new defence against the dark arts teacher - Mad-Eye Moody, a retired auror (dark wizard catcher) whose gnarled features are a very visible sign of his years of service and subsequent paranoia. As for Harry, Ron, and Hermione, they find their hormones taking over as adolescence hits and they start seeing the opposite sex as something more than asexual companions. Harry struggles bravely through the tournament, less knowledgeable than his competitors, but always willing to face his fears. However, the final task proves more perilous than could have been imagined and a dark twist at the novel's conclusion thrusts Harry into dark and terrifying situations once more.

Harry's entry into the Tri-Wizard tournament as an under-age competitor reflects his wider life, where he has been consistently thrust into situations he hasn't asked for and which are more than anyone of his young age could rightly be expected to face. The tournament sets wizarding schools against one another and this highlights the dangers of chasing individual glory at the expense of co-operation and community. As the champions attempt to gain an advantage over their competitors they prove themselves capable of lying, cheating, and becoming completely single-minded. However, there are moments too where they choose to selflessly assist each other, whether through a shared need to succeed or a sense of what's 'right'. Though Harry is occasionally seduced by the idea of winning the tournament and receiving all the glory and plaudits, he never becomes enthralled and doesn't allow the potential success to corrupt his self. That the competitors are able to become friends by the end of the tournament is testament to the strength and merit of co-operation over single-minded self-progression.

Rowling makes some powerful statements about fairness and diversity, the nature of courage, and friendship. Voldemort is the posionous antithesis of all these virtues; a pitiless loner who chooses to command rather than connect with people, and who loves power. As ever Rowling affirms the values of courage and fairness, of finding the strength to stand against what is wrong in oneself and one's friends. As ever, the reader is taught not to jump to conclusions. From Mad-Eye Moody to the mysterious merpeople, very little is how it is first represented and Harry and the reader learn to accept cautiously and not to rely on pre-conceptions when forming judgements.

Harry is surrounded by injustice, from the apathetic misuse of house elves by the majority of the wizarding world to the cruel elitism of the Death Eaters. Hermione battles the enslavement of the houselves who, as uneducated and voiceless servants, are tied to their wizarding family and forced to do whatever they are commanded. This refusal to accept intolerance and the misuse of inferiors is the flipside of Voldemort's contempt for everyone he considers to be outside his selected group of 'pure-bloods'. Sweeping and mindless hate like this is seen as the great evil and, in her own small way, Hermione's fight against the oppression of houselves, which has at its heart compassion and a will to accept uncomfortable truths, offers the solution to hatred and prejudice.

As well as the new interest in romance and the sexual tension between certain characters, there are other elements of adolescence that become obvious, most clearly self-awareness. Here, the young characters become more self-conscious, worrying about how their actions are perceived by others and where they sit within the social hierarchy. To make matters worse, Harry's involvement in the tournament means he becomes a serious media target and is hounded throughout the year by tabloid journalist Rita Skeeter - this is a nice bit of satire and demonstrates the parasitic side of the media, which by this point Rowling herself would have experienced, and warns of the dangers that come along with fame. Through Skeeter's pursuit of him, Harry becomes increasingly aware that he has a public image to be managed as well as a private one.

Rowling's writing takes on a new richness here. There are some wonderfully vivid scenes, notably the Quidditch World Cup and the Yule ball, both events which paint a richer picture of the wizarding world whilst blending it with our own, and sculpting a vivid memory for the reader. However, when all the detail is stripped away the plot is a little disappointing, with little drive and too little genuine conflict until the latter stages. The villain's account at the end, which explains all that came before, is a fairly poor device and doesn't wholly make up for the lack of direction early on. Added to this the plot feels unnecessarily convoluted at times, in particular the ridiculously circuitous and unreliable route taken to achieve the ends of having Harry touch the port key at the novel's conclusion when any object could have been used at any point. Yet the novel's final set-piece is wonderful - as Rowling has demonstrated previously, she knows how to write thrilling, and poignant conclusions to her books. This is no exception.

The main characters become ever more complex and their teenage angst provides an extra dimension to them as heroes. Other than Harry's increasing self-consciousness, perhaps the most interesting development here is Ron and Hermione's relationship as it begins to hint at something more than friendship. In contrast, while other characters evolve around him, Malfoy is oddly stagnant at this point, failing to develop beyond the stereotypical bully. His development comes later in the series than most, and this sticks out increasingly as the majority of the ongoing characters only become more refined and complex.

The Goblet of Fire is the first book that ends on a down, and this is important leading into the darker, more perilous books in the series, where the real sense that things won't work out perfectly is only enhanced by having Harry face truly bleak outcomes. As Harry begins to develop a greater self-awareness so too he becomes more aware of the outside world and how he fits into it - for the first time he truly appreciates how wide the wizarding world that he is a part of really is. With some brilliant set-pieces, The Goblet of Fire provides some of the most memorable scenes from the series as a whole and this, more than anything, is why it is one of the most enjoyed of the Potter books.

There are some truly memorable scenes in this, and the characters become increasingly interesting and angsty. Lots to enjoy.


Useful Links
Reviews of Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire on Amazon (UK)
Reviews of Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire on Amazon (US)
Film adaptation of Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire on Amazon (UK)
Film adaptation of Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire on Amazon (US)

You Might Also Enjoy... 

Review: Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone by J. K. Rowling
Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone (1997) is the first book in J. K. Rowling’s best-selling series. Here the reader is introduced to Harry Potter, an unassuming orphan who lives with his Aunt Petunia and Uncle Vernon, and their son Dudley... [Read More]
Review: Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets by J. K. Rowling
Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets (1998) is the second book in J. K. Rowling’s wildly popular series, and sees its hero once again faced with tests more demanding than any boy of his age could be expected to confront. Back in Privet Drive... [Read More]
Vowel Play #002: Harry Potter Characters
Many of us grew up reading the Harry Potter series and have fond memories of all the wonderful characters that J. K. Rowling filled her books with, but how many can you spot in the list below? The vowels have been removed, and you need at least first... [Read More]

No comments: